Experian

The Challenge

How might we leverage alternative data sources to help people with low FICO credit scores?

The Insight

Millions of consumers who lack credit history or have experienced financial distress in the past have difficulty obtaining or increasing credit from mainstream financial institutions.

The Solution

Through cohesive user experience, we designed desktop and mobile interfaces that leverage financial transactions to increase credit scores and broaden financial inclusion for Americans.

Date

February - August 2019

Role : Senior UX/UI Designer

  • Design Research
  • Strategic Design
  • Visual Design
  • User Experience
  • User Testing
  • Prototyping

Project Summary

Experian is a global leader in consumer and business credit reporting and marketing services that gather, analyze, and process credit data. Experian helps individuals by offering access to financial services; it helps lenders minimize risks; and it helps businesses make better, more informed decisions.

Experian Boost

Experian Boost is a service that rewards customers for responsible financial behavior by increasing their credit scores. Experian Boost connects to your bank account(s) to find qualifying on-time bill payments and, with your permission, adds those payments to your credit file. The process takes about five minutes, and you'll see any changes to your credit scores instantly. Most people who try Experian Boost immediately see their credit scores improve.

image

Objective: Tradestream Rent

Through partnership with Finicity, the Experian project enhanced the consumer borrowing experience by accelerating loan underwriting and broadening loan availability. It used a web and mobile interface design for Boost features, using data from the mortgage and rent industry.

The design focuses only on bills for utilities that the “boostable” population is not leveraging. The new app design is intended to reach that subset of the consumer base by ensuring design has sufficient information to improve consumer’s FICO® Score minimum scoring criteria.

image

Potential impact in the rental industry

35% of Americans' rent and monthly payments are not helping their credit score. Some renters don’t pay for their utilities directly, making their rental payment one of the only neglected transaction streams that could help improve their credit score.

The Experience Pillars through User Research

The design needs to "Communicate With them"

Consumers believe design should speak to them in ways they can understand and make it easy to find answers to their questions.

The design needs to "Guide them"

The interaction design should show users what they can do, tell them what to expect, and help them along the way so they feel empowered to move forward.

The design needs to "Motivate them"

The design needs to show users the value that makes this worth their time and encourages them to complete the process.

Today’s Consumer Experience
Meet Jerry

Plans to build a business independently, currently works two jobs and does not make large purchases with his credit card. He has difficulty building his credit score.

  • Late 20’s
  • $62,000 annual income
  • Renter
  • Relatively new to credit
  • Pays bills on time, for the most part; has a couple of credit cards with balances
  • Traditional FICO® Score of 679 places him in “grey zone” of common new credit card FICO® Score cutoff
  • Will likely qualify for card offers, but with less favorable features that could negatively affect him
Future Credit Experience
Get to Know Jerry Better…

Hoping to buy a house, he always makes rent payments on time and is not aware that those payments can be used as investments toward his credit score.

  • He has robust DDA history not captured in a traditional bureau
  • He agrees to share access to his DDA data
  • Transaction history secured via Finicity to generate his enhanced FICO® Score
  • His positive behaviors boost his FICO® Score 8 by 22 points
  • A FICO® Score of 701 makes him more attractive to lenders, resulting in better offers surfaced and increasing the likelihood of take up

How it Works

Leveraging Financial Transaction Data

The UltraFICO™ Score incorporates transnational data from consumer’s checking, savings, and money market accounts. It extends the scorable population and refines prediction to broaden financial inclusion

Projecting a strong upward shift in scores seen in key segments like the thin and/or young credit files/credit files with previous derogatory information. Overall we will see positive shifts in all other segments

Drivers of Experian Boost

  • Maintaining a bank account over time
  • Regularly paying bills and making other banking transactions
  • Saving and keeping a healthy average balance
  • Avoiding a negative balance
Competitive Analysis

In the early stages, we analyzed our competitors, noting their respective weaknesses and strengths. We hoped to avoid their weaknesses while solving their problems, ultimately creating a competitive feature that optimizes Experian Boost’s unique positioning.

Competitive Name Weakness Our response
Credit Karma Credit Karma does not make use of FICO scores; instead, it leverages a less common credit evaluation metric. FICO integration means Experian leverages the best credit evaluation metric. The app would need to highlight the advantage of Experian’s Boost’s instant FICO improvement
Equifax Equifax offers virtually the same services as Experian; however, its apps have generally poor reviews on the Apple App Store (Equifax’s “Lock and Alert” app has more 1-star-reviews than any other user score). Reported weaknesses include the user interface, poor functionality, and complexity The Experian app would provide a new, more specific, instant way for people to improve their FICO scores. It can capture even customers who will continue to use FICO products

The Experian Boost App would need to provide an experience different from the clunky, frustrating experience provided by Equifax; we decided to simplify the design wherever possible.
Competitive Analysis

In the early stages, we analyzed our competitors, noting their respective weaknesses and strengths. We hoped to avoid their weaknesses while solving their problems, ultimately creating a competitive feature that optimizes Experian Boost’s unique positioning.

Competitive Name
Credit Karma
Equifax
Weakness
Credit Karma
F
Our response
Equifax
Equifax offers virtually the same services as Experian; however, its apps have generally poor reviews on the Apple App Store (Equifax’s “Lock and Alert” app has more 1-star-reviews than any other user score). Reported weaknesses include the user interface, poor functionality, and complexity
The Experian app would provide a new, more specific, instant way for people to improve their FICO scores. It can capture even customers who will continue to use FICO products

The Experian Boost App would need to provide an experience different from the clunky, frustrating experience provided by Equifax; we decided to simplify the design wherever possible.
image

Defining Requirements

The team set key requirements that the final design needed to meet. Experian Boost’s app should:

  • Build trust with consumers by Integrating advanced security features, progressive disclosure and choice architecture design
  • Verification of income process through bank API integration
  • Built to client specifications and branding requirements
  • Supports in/out-of-band user experiences
  • Effectively educate the consumer about the process and benefits of Experian Boost
  • Work in partnership to design a pilot to assess key metrics such as Conversion rates, scorable rates, and score changes

image Loges Smith

Future Biologist

Age: 27 Gender: Female

Personal Bio

Lourdes, a 19-year old, hopes to be a first-generation college graduate. She will apply to her bank for an education loanmus.

image Daniel Cour

Future pre-law student

Age: 28 Gender: Male

Personal Bio

Daniel, hoping to buy a house, always makes rent payments on time and is not aware that those payments can be used as investments toward his credit score.

image Mike Revies

Future Biologist

Age: 21 Gender: Male

Personal Bio

Mike, who plans to build a business independently, currently works two jobs and does not make large purchases with his credit card. He has difficulty building his FICO score.

Mind Mapping Activity

image

Implementation of UI

Only 20-30% of rentals are professionally managed by third parties. Individual landlords manage the rest. This will make it hard to build out a definitive list or to establish a data format to help identify rent trade streams.

The less information we demand from customers, the more they will sign up for this service.
We could have them upload rental agreements or provide an example of a transaction they make to their landlord if we need to.

We designed the UI fields needed for customers to navigate the app. We asked various questions to help our understanding so that customers could seamlessly input information into the interface.

Low Fidelity

We created a low-fidelity mock-up demonstrating the basic features of the app and mapping the relationships between various screens.

image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image

Identify payment streams for utilities and rent that match users’ bank accounts. The verification process is done through transaction aggregations through API integration of users’ bank account data.

image

More questions that arose when designing the interface were: What does Normalized Payee look like for rent? Is the name of the landlord or a third-party representative used as the NP?

How can users gather and input information about their rental transactions? What do most rental transactions look like?

image
image

What patterns exist in rental transactions that can be easily added to the TS identification engine? Can we make use of first-month security deposits for verification? 


Interactive Prototype

Others who will benefit immediately from quick access to Experian Boost:

  • Single parents.
  • Students making basic rent payments
  • Hard-working, responsible people who do not make wide use of credit cards
  • Anyone who will need a large loan in future
  • Anyone who needs a strong credit score and also needs to make higher-risk investments, such as entrepreneurs

TradeStreams

We researched digital pathways for financial information, connecting sources such as:

  • Utilities (Address match to rent address)
  • Landlord name after doing EDA
  • Checking accounts (30-35% have attached tradestream investment accounts)
  • Other Statistics
  • Rent-to-own agreements

Brainstorming Ideas

We created a list of important ideas and sources of financial information that may be helpful to integrate with the app:

  • Current monthly payments (Mortgage/Rent)
  • Redshift EDA
  • Checks, ACH, cadence
  • Rentler, Landlords/PMS
  • Mobility (AirBNB)
  • Office Space (rent)

Interview
The app conducts an “interview” to verify applicants pay their rent regularly. It asks users to provide information about the times' rent is paid, the cadence of payments (how often they occur), information about the landlord, and the method of bill payment.

Normalized Payee
All selected transactions are processed to determine eligibility by identifying rent/bill payees

Add Accounts
The user is asked to select which account or accounts they use to pay their rent or other bills.

Confirmation
The app analyzes users’ bank accounts, identifying their transactions and verifying that they pay rent

Results

More than 1.3 million American consumers have completed the Boost process, and more than 840,000 of them saw their FICO scores increase. Impressive 86% of the thin file ( “thin” credit histories–meaning they don’t have many credit accounts to report on-time payments) consumers using Boost have seen an instant FICO 8 Score increase, averaging 19 points.

image

Experian Boost raised my FICO® Score 47 points. It’s free, easy and there’s no reason not to do it.

Nora V.

So with Experian Boost I raised my credit scores by 17 points. It’s crazy!

Clairissa L.
image
image

I was able to raise my FICO® Score using Experian Boost.

Maniecsha H.

It feels great. 37 points! Instantly my credit scores was raised.

Jonathan C.
image
image

Experian Boost helped me raise my FICO® Score 6 points. Being able to do it instantly fits into my lifestyle.

Luisa R.

A 19 point boost! It makes you feel like, alright, I can control this.

Hannah B.
image
image

Experian Boost raised my FICO® Score 47 points. It’s free, easy and there’s no reason not to do it.

Nora V.
image

So with Experian Boost I raised my credit scores by 17 points. It’s crazy!

Clairissa L.
image

I was able to raise my FICO® Score using Experian Boost.

Maniecsha H.
image

It feels great. 37 points! Instantly my credit scores was raised.

Jonathan C.
image

Experian Boost helped me raise my FICO® Score 6 points. Being able to do it instantly fits into my lifestyle.

Luisa R.
image

A 19 point boost! It makes you feel like, alright, I can control this.

Hannah B.

User Design Interface

image

Boost is projected to benefit 7 million consumers who fall into the upper 500 to low 600 FICO score range — usually just under a lender’s minimum credit threshold. It should also help the 15 million Americans who have no credit score at all (due to never taking out a loan, applying for a credit card, etc.)

Conclusion

Up to 35% of Americans could instantly improve their FICO credit scores using Experian’s Boost service. Experian Boost is free, so potential users are missing out, either because they do not know about the benefits, they do not feel they have time, or other reasons.

The Experian Boost App responds to this problem by creating a seamless, easy-entry app, allowing users to securely and conveniently link their accounts to Experian Boost. The UI design is simple, yet each step educates the user about the process and allows control over financial information and rent transaction history. Users can easily begin the process without previous preparation, removing some potential users’ objections.

Brainstorming, market research, and competitive analysis led to a strategizing process. The design team responded to current problems and responded to competitors’ weaknesses. Then, the most important features were mapped into a low-fidelity mockup. From there, user interface and other design features were incorporated into high-fidelity mockups and prototypes. The complete app offers a streamlined interaction that captures Experian’s Three Experience Pillars.