After completing my PhD in Transition Design, I found myself confronting an uncomfortable tension in the design discourse around me.
My professional practice and doctoral work had overlapped. I wasn’t returning to industry from somewhere outside it. But doctoral research had deepened my understanding of design as a practice that engages with interconnected systems, institutional conditions, and consequences unfolding over time. Meanwhile, parts of the industry conversation seemed increasingly concerned with how much an exceptional individual could produce.
The Super IC captured that emphasis: a designer close to the craft, capable of moving across responsibilities, potentially using AI to accelerate execution.
I understand the appeal. Staying close to the work is a legitimate ambition. Not every designer wants to manage people, and management should not be the price of meaningful influence. A principal designer can shape strategy without a single direct report.
What concerns me is what organizations may ask individual excellence to replace.
A designer can become more productive while design becomes less influential.
Better execution does not necessarily bring greater participation in defining problems, allocating resources, or determining what an organization should pursue.
The Super IC is not inherently the problem. Its prominence may be a symptom of a deeper shift in what design is valued for.
The decisions beneath the career debate
I think of this as a question about the political economy of design: how investment, rewards, resources, and decision-making power shape the work design is able to do.
Who sets the problem before a designer receives it? Which capabilities receive funding? What earns recognition: shipping an interface, changing a roadmap, improving how teams make decisions, or identifying a consequence that makes an intervention worth reconsidering?
These choices position design either as a contributor to institutional direction or as an execution function within a direction already settled.
Delivery matters. Organizations have deadlines, financial constraints, and commitments to meet. The problem begins when immediate output becomes the only credible evidence of design’s value. Work that improves problem framing, builds organizational capability, or addresses longer-term consequences can then appear peripheral because its contribution is harder to isolate.
This is not a description of every organization. It is the pattern I’m concerned about in parts of contemporary design practice. The celebration of individual productivity becomes troubling when it gives organizations permission to stop investing in the collective capabilities around it.
Design may preserve its immediate relevance while weakening its longer-term influence.
What I mean by Big Design
Tricia Douglas, a colleague in Carnegie Mellon’s Transition Design program, introduced me to Big Design through an analogy with Big Tech. As I remember it, her provocation concerned the ambition and reach design needs in a world shaped so extensively by technology.
I understood that invitation as reaching beyond traditional craft and product design, with particular emphasis on transformational design and interconnected systems. What follows is my interpretation of that provocation, not a claim to reproduce a formal framework she established.
The question it raises for me is straightforward: if technology helps shape institutions, economies, communities, and societal conditions, what capabilities must design develop to engage meaningfully with those consequences?
Big Design does not mean larger teams, more senior titles, or more interfaces. Nor does it mean designers acquiring authority over other disciplines and communities.
It means extending design’s capacity to act across the relationships between artifacts, organizations, and societal systems.
Traditional design and craft, product and service design, organizational design, and transformational design offer different ways into that work. They are not sequential stages or a hierarchy of professional worth. They overlap.
Transformational design expands attention beyond the immediate artifact toward the institutional arrangements, relationships, and conditions through which artifacts and experiences are produced. It asks whether those conditions need to change, not only whether the resulting product can be improved. That ambition still depends on careful execution: institutional change is encountered through the details of services, tools, and everyday interactions.
I use Big Design here neither as another name for organizational design nor as a substitute for Transition Design. It connects a broader ambition for design with the capabilities and institutional support needed to pursue it, and with responsibility for what follows.
Four qualities help explain that ambition.
Scale means connecting an immediate intervention to the wider conditions it depends on and may change. Integration means participating in how an organization coordinates work and makes decisions, rather than arriving only to shape the final expression. Influence means helping determine priorities and direction, not simply responding to them.
Responsibility must accompany all three. The further design’s reach extends, the more seriously it must consider who experiences the consequences and who can challenge its decisions.
The Big Tech analogy is useful for thinking about reach. It is not a license to reproduce concentrated authority. Consequential design needs accountability, not professional dominion.
Design Currency
I use the term Design Currency to describe meaningful influence beyond shipped artifacts.
Craft is one of its foundations. The quality of what we make matters, and close attention to use can reveal problems that strategic discussion misses. But craft alone cannot determine whether an organization listens to those discoveries or acts on them.
Design Currency also depends on relationships with organizational strategy, leadership and decision-making capacity, and responsibility for longer-term consequences.
These capacities reinforce one another. Craft gives substance to strategic claims. Organizational knowledge helps designers understand where decisions can change. Leadership creates room for expertise to affect commitments and resources. A longer-term perspective tests whether a convincing immediate solution is taking the institution in a direction worth pursuing.
None of this belongs exclusively to people managers.
An executive title does not guarantee influence. A principal designer may have considerable Design Currency because colleagues trust their judgment and because the organization gives that judgment a meaningful place in decisions. A design leader may have very little if they are accountable for delivery but excluded from defining priorities.
Design Currency is my practitioner language for these relationships, not a validated measurement model. Its purpose is to redirect attention from status to capacity: can design expertise actually change what the organization decides to do?
Shaping the conditions of work
Across my professional and scholarly work, I’ve become concerned with the difference between improving an artifact and improving the conditions under which artifacts are conceived, built, and maintained.
The latter includes how teams coordinate, when research enters a decision, which uncertainties remain open for investigation, and whether someone has the authority to revisit an assumption before it hardens into a commitment.
This is what I mean by shaping the conditions of work itself.
Consider two hypothetical situations involving the same capable principal designer.
In one, the designer joins after the problem, scope, and delivery commitments are fixed. Relevant information sits elsewhere, and there is little time to investigate assumptions. The mandate may be strategic in name, but the available influence is largely corrective: improve the proposed solution without reconsidering its premise.
In the other, the designer participates in defining the problem, can work directly with colleagues across disciplines, and has resources for inquiry. It is clear which decisions they can make and which they can influence. Contributions to reframing the problem are recognized alongside delivery, and responsibility includes returning to the work to examine its consequences.
The individual’s capability has not changed. The institution’s capacity to use it has.
The same applies across organizational boundaries. Asking designers to think systemically means little if their goals, schedules, and recognition remain confined to a single team’s immediate output.
Big Design therefore requires institutional support. It cannot depend on unusually persuasive individuals repeatedly working around the organization’s arrangements.
My Transition Design background sharpens this concern. It encourages me to connect an intervention to the conditions around it and to consequences beyond its immediate delivery. In professional practice, that means asking not only whether a design works, but whether the organization is equipped to recognize and respond to what the work reveals.
Why the Super IC cannot carry this alone
An exceptional individual contributor can contribute to all of this. There is nothing inherently narrow about an IC career.
The distinction is between the role a person chooses and the organizational bargain built around that role.
One bargain gives a senior IC the relationships, time, and decision-making access to connect craft with broader direction. Another asks that person to absorb more execution while investment in research, leadership, and organizational development recedes.
Both may be described as empowering exceptional talent. They are not the same proposition.
AI belongs in this discussion because of the expectations attached to it. Where it helps a designer accelerate part of the work, an organization still has to decide what that capacity is for. It might create room for deeper inquiry and broader collaboration. It might instead become a reason to demand more output from fewer people.
The tool does not settle that choice.
My concern is not that the Super IC has caused design’s decline. It is that the narrative can make a narrowing of design’s recognized value look like an expansion of professional freedom.
The craft becomes exceptional while the capacity to question direction remains weak.
Influence requires accountability
Design’s response cannot simply be to demand a larger mandate.
If we want influence over organizational and societal conditions, we must be clearer about how that influence remains accountable to people affected by the work.
Who defines a desirable outcome? Whose knowledge informs the problem? Who benefits from an intervention, and who bears costs that do not appear in the project’s measures of success?
These questions place limits on professional authority. Designers can help make relationships and consequences visible, bring competing perspectives into a decision, and propose alternatives. That does not give us the right to decide on behalf of everyone involved.
Working across systems also means accepting that no design team controls the whole. Other professions, public institutions, workers, users, and communities hold knowledge and responsibilities that design cannot absorb.
Greater influence should therefore bring stronger obligations to collaborate, explain assumptions, invite challenge, and revise a direction when its consequences warrant it.
For me, this is essential to Big Design. Without it, the concept risks becoming a claim for professional importance rather than a more responsible practice.
What design organizations should cultivate
The alternative is to develop craft and broader capability together.
Support senior IC pathways with genuine strategic influence. Give experienced contributors opportunities to help frame problems and participate in consequential decisions. Don’t make management the only route to that participation.
Invest in leadership and organizational development. This is not a demand to restore particular titles. It is a demand for the capacity to build teams, negotiate priorities, develop people, and maintain the relationships through which design contributes to direction.
Recognize contributions that shape the conditions of work. Improving a decision process, connecting teams around an unresolved problem, or changing a roadmap in response to research can matter alongside the artifact eventually shipped. These contributions need credible accounts of what changed, not vague assertions of strategic impact.
Create opportunities to work across boundaries. Designers need enough organizational and systems literacy to understand dependencies beyond their immediate remit, alongside opportunities to learn with people who know those conditions more deeply.
These are recommendations, not a claim that one program or career structure will work everywhere. They ask organizations to examine whether their investment and recognition match the breadth of contribution they say they want from design.
The Super IC can be part of that future. Exceptional craft deserves support, and an IC career should offer more than a choice between execution and management.
But the future of design as a discipline cannot rest on individual excellence alone. Its transformational ambition needs collective capability and strategic influence, sustained by institutions that allow design to question direction as well as execute it.
The stakes extend beyond the profession. The conditions under which design works affect which needs enter a brief, which alternatives receive consideration, and whose consequences remain visible after delivery. Organizational capability matters because it helps determine whether responsibility for those consequences can become part of practice rather than remain an aspiration.
That is the ambition I see in Big Design: craft connected to institutional capability, and influence held accountable to the people it affects.
It asks us to build the conditions in which detail, direction, and systems rise together.